crash_reports: 2000000011

On Friday 1/3/20 at approximately 1834 hours while assigned to marked unit n504 patrolling sector 499 I was dispatched to the intersection of Brookline Street and Vine Street for a report of a minor motor vehicle crash with no injuries. Upon arrival I spoke with the operator of vehicle #1, HORN Paul, who states that he was travelling on Vine Street and was stopped at the stop sign waiting to turn left onto Brookline Street. HORN states Motor Vehicle #2 was taking a left onto Vine Street from Brookline Street and turned to sharp striking the front drivers side of his vehicle. HORN states that he was not moving as he was waiting for traffic to clear. After speaking with HORN I spoke to the operator of Motor Vehicle #2, QIAN Xiaohua, who states that she was turning left from Brookline Street onto Vine Street. She states while turning left she didnt see Vehicle #1 waiting to turn and she struck the front of his vehile causing damage to the drivers side door of her vehicle. After hearing from both parties involved and observing the damage to both vehicles it appears to me that the operator of MV#2 (QIAN) violated the right of way of MV #1 (HORN). The statement by HORN that he was not moving and was simply waiting to turn is consistent with the damage to the vehicles. Had HORN been moving the damage would have occurred to the Passengers side of his vehicle and the front drivers side of vehicle#2 (QIAN). The statements made by both operators and my observations lead me to believe that the operator of MV#2 (QIAN) is at fault for this Crash